Two-thousand years before Isaac Newton was born, an unknown Greek reflects upon the world convinced there must be some order to the chaos. We imagine our hero come beard-to-beard with Aristotle's crude physics -- spurred on, we imagine, by recent tragedy: a brother's trireme lost off the coast of Attica in a storm.
Aristotle consoles. The sailor drowned because the bottom of the ocean is the natural place for him.
This vexes our hero (let us call him/her Kittycules), for s/he observes some things do not seek the bottom of the ocean. Ducks, exempli gratia. Witches. Very small rocks.
Because that, too, is their natural place, Aristotle retorts undeterred. Very tremendously natural place. Lots of people are saying that.
It cannot be denied Aristotle's physics leaves much to be desired. Talk of "things seeking their natural place" looks nice on a bumper sticker, but it don't provide a useful tool. However, what form would a useful tool assume? It would take two millennia (and a plague) for humans to work that out.
But it need not have.
Aristotle consoles. The sailor drowned because the bottom of the ocean is the natural place for him.
This vexes our hero (let us call him/her Kittycules), for s/he observes some things do not seek the bottom of the ocean. Ducks, exempli gratia. Witches. Very small rocks.
Because that, too, is their natural place, Aristotle retorts undeterred. Very tremendously natural place. Lots of people are saying that.
It cannot be denied Aristotle's physics leaves much to be desired. Talk of "things seeking their natural place" looks nice on a bumper sticker, but it don't provide a useful tool. However, what form would a useful tool assume? It would take two millennia (and a plague) for humans to work that out.
But it need not have.

